| Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision | |
| statistics:pvalue_corrections [2026/09/04 17:30] – Citekey consolidation 2026-09-04: repoint duplicate bibliography keys (fouad2022my/boettger2025_regional/ahmad2026_ipfp/bouhoula2024automated/lerner2016internet) to the kept key; no prose or figure changed. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude | statistics:pvalue_corrections [2026/09/21 13:34] (current) – Quote bullet refreshed against quote_check.mjs with the pypdf fallback: 167/63/40 rescued/22 below in both, of 292. Authored by Claude karel.kubicek.claude |
|---|
| * **A paper counts once**, never once per mention. 292 tuples across 269 papers. | * **A paper counts once**, never once per mention. 292 tuples across 269 papers. |
| * **''statistics.kind'' is a mid-band field**: two independent extraction runs over identical text agreed on it for 68% of papers, so a repeat run would move these percentages by a few points. That caveat applies to every share on this page and does not apply to the folded procedure ranking, which is a ranking. | * **''statistics.kind'' is a mid-band field**: two independent extraction runs over identical text agreed on it for 68% of papers, so a repeat run would move these percentages by a few points. That caveat applies to every share on this page and does not apply to the folded procedure ranking, which is a ranking. |
| * **Quotes were checked.** All 292 correction quotes were run against ''paper.cols.txt'': 167 exact, 63 partial (≥60% of five-word windows), 62 below that threshold — mostly extractor ellipses and dropped citation markers. Every quote used on this page was then located by hand in the source; **all 18 checked out**, one of them (Pu & Grossklags) only after the extractor's ''...'' was expanded. See [[provenance:statistics:pvalue_corrections]]. | * **Quotes were checked.** All 292 correction quotes were run against the rendering the extractor read and then, for anything below threshold, against an independent ''pypdf'' rendering of the same ''paper.pdf'': 167 exact, 63 partial (≥60% of five-word windows), **40 located only in the second rendering** — a defect in the stored text, not in the extraction — and **22 (7.5%) below threshold in both**, mostly extractor ellipses and dropped citation markers on quotes short enough that one marker moves most of the windows. Every quote used on this page was then located by hand in the source; **all 18 checked out**, one of them (Pu & Grossklags) only after the extractor's ''...'' was expanded. See [[provenance:statistics:pvalue_corrections]]. |
| * **Venue coverage.** Seven venues. EuroS&P, ACSAC, RAID, AsiaCCS, WPES, CHI and **SOUPS** are absent, and SOUPS matters most: it is where the usable-privacy work that corrects most reliably would appear, so the correction rate here is if anything flattered by its absence. | * **Venue coverage.** Seven venues. EuroS&P, ACSAC, RAID, AsiaCCS, WPES, CHI and **SOUPS** are absent, and SOUPS matters most: it is where the usable-privacy work that corrects most reliably would appear, so the correction rate here is if anything flattered by its absence. |
| * **2025 and 2026 are provisional.** See the box above. | * **2025 and 2026 are provisional.** See the box above. |
